Pelco uses 2 different protocols to send PTZ (Pan, Tilt, Zoom) commands to cameras: Pelco D and Pelco P. I'd like to understand the difference from a high-level perspective. Are they meant for different use cases? Is one more feature-complete than the other? What are their practical differences?
What I've found so far
Pelco-D is a popular PTZ (Pan / Tilt / Zoom) camera control protocol used in the CCTV industry.
Besides Pelco-D, Pelco-P is another popular PTZ (Pan / Tilt / Zoom) camera control protocol used in the CCTV industry.
which doesn't really help.
Then there's this thread where a user says that
- D Protocol is a type serial protocol of sending/receiving data from the controller to camera for the pan /tilt and zoom functions. In D protocol separate data cable is required rather than the cable for video.
- P Protocol is a type of superimposing the data signal over the video signal in the same cable (i.e. in case of coaxial cable transmission same coaxial cable will be used to carry the data signal along with the video without additional cables).
But another user replied that this description is wrong:
You are right about D Protocol but P and D are similar, both needing a separate control wire. What you think P Protocol is actually is called Coaxitron. Coaxitron sends the control over the coaxial cable. D and P differ on baud rates and max units able to control but are pretty similar. Coaxitron control needs both a coaxitron able camera plus a coaxitron able controller like a CXT or a MXB with coaxitron capability. Pelco's new network video recording system Endura also uses coaxitron. As you can probably tell Coaxitron is a Pelco thing, i'm not sure if any other manufacturer uses it. The only road block with it is that it can't send control through any active transmission system like a Signal Amplifier or a Powered UTP unit. Hope this helps.
Both messages are very old (from 2005 and 2006).
Another user there said he worked for Pelco and left his email address; by googling it I was able to find this question on Electronics Stack Exchange which says that Pelco P is an earlier version. The same employee answered and then commented that he is no longer working for Pelco.
This is all I've found. Can anybody tell me more about the difference between Pelco D and Pelco P?