3

I have build a door sensor where arduino uno reads reed switch and transmits RF 433MHz signal to other Arduino uno connected RF receiver. I am using rcswitch library and cheap ask/ook transmitter/ receiver modules from AliExpress. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32644105493.html

The range I get is less then 1m. This is with 17 cm 0.6mm straight wire connected as antenna on transmitter as well as receiver. I read on internet that these receiver modules are noisy and useless.

Will the transmitter I have work with HC12 receiver module? I want a 15-20m range to cover all doors and windows.

Idea is to use many such cheap transmitters and one good receiver at central place to keep the overall cost low.

  • @Tim_Stewart hope you will manage some time to answer this soon. – suresh hariramani May 22 at 16:42
  • 1
    I will work on it in weekend. I am highly optimistic your way will increase the range. Couple of weeks back I made coil antenna using wire stripped from CAT-6 cable. After your Answer I know why it did not work (CAT-6 wire is not enameled). I was driving Transmitter power from Attiny13 Pin (around 4v). Now I will use 9V battery to power transmitter. I will update in weekend, how much increase in range brought by these 02 changes. – suresh hariramani May 27 at 7:50
  • Any luck with this? – Tim_Stewart Jun 8 at 22:30
1

I also couldn't help but to succumb to the temptation of these cheap 433.92Mhz Rx/Tx pairs. Mine are of the eBay variety ($0.89 a pair with free shipping).

I observed the same behavior with 1/4 wave whips attached to these, although not quite as bad as you describe. Through tinkering I found lower AWG sized enameled wiring to give slightly better results, about an extra two meters using 23AWG enameled magnet wire line of sight, but was barely penetrating the drywall to the next room... Not good enough for my projects unfortunately, so back to the drawing boards I went.

As a side note, the quarter wave whip had to be spiraled in my project boxes which will change the radiation pattern of the antenna. (Found this out when I turned to my RTL-SDR for troubleshooting)

A friend told me to try a "coil-loaded antenna" which is an antenna with air-cored inductor. Did some searches for 433Mhz coil-loaded antennas and found plenty of results, including calculators to build them for any frequency desired. These types of antennas also have the added benefit of changing the size of our wave-guide to a more compact form.

Here is a step by step PDF for building 433.92Mhz Coil-Loaded antennas written by Ben Schueler (NL). I was very pleased with the performance of these DIY antennas. I also was still using the 23AWG to make them,(make sure its enamel insulated or it will not work) which wound up being very close to these instructions designated magnet wire size. It still didn't reach the far end of the house on the second floor...

Here is an interesting bit about the transmitter, I didn't find this info in any instructions for these. My eBay seller had this listed in the description section of the listing for them.

cheap 433.93Mhz


Ah, the plot thickens. I highly refute this distance listed for the transmitter, and unless i just missed something I'm calling b.s... So, here is what i gathered from tinkering with them.

On a 3.3v Rail

  • Extremely poor transmit distance for the 3 out of 5 I ordered (3 transmitted a couple feet and two wouldn't TX at all at this voltage while watching it on the SDR.)
  • Wouldn't recommend these for any 3.3 volt microprocessor project unless the transmitter is on a separate voltage rail.

On a 5v Rail

  • With the coil loaded antennas the Tx distance was reasonable. (About 75~100ft LOS) I wouldn't expect miracles if you have concrete walls to penetrate.
  • This voltage will probably cover most projects with these antennas.

5v and above

I used one of these cheap ebay boost modules cheap boost module mainly because I already had some, and I am pretty lazy when it comes to making circuits like this. I carefully adjusted the 10k pot while watching the voltage with a multi meter, each +1 voltage step I tested the range.

Here is what I found:

  • 6v,7v,8v,9v all had increase in range in proportion with the the step-up. (5 out of 5 transmitters)
  • 9.5v~11.5v Again three transmitters showed slight distance improvements, but also had heat developing at the module at about 10.5v. (Wasted power) and the other two showed no improvement at all after 10v.
  • 12-Volt, yea... Don't do 12v, its clearly the absolute maximum rating as my test module went up in a $0.44 puff of noxious smoke.

All in all these aren't bad for the price, (If you know the above information) The sweet spot voltage for these seem to be in the 9-volt range as it doesn't heat up, and gets pretty decent distance. (My max was 250ft LOS, keep in mind my transmissions are 8bit codes).

I hope this helps you and future readers out with projects!

| improve this answer | |
  • This worked for me. I tested with receiver connected to wemos-d1 (3.3v) and transmitter connected to UNO (5v) and got the range approx 10m. It cannot penetrate any walls so I will add one receiver in every room. Another points which I think affect range are following > Good Ground Plane (Increases range) > Vicinity of other wireless signals like WiFi, Mobiles (Decreases range) – suresh hariramani Jun 10 at 4:14

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.